Johnston & Murphy Men's McGuffey Oiled Leather Plain Toe Casual Shoe

Quality: check.Looks: check.Value for money: CheckOverall: Great Product. 5 star for me

My son bought a pair of shoes from this brand a few months back before leaving for 2 years. He also took an older pair from another brand which wore out quickly and became uncomfortable. He asked for this brand specifically and has been very happy with his second pair . He now has a black and brown pair and we recommend this brand. Good quality.

I’ve really enjoyed these Johnson Murphy McGuffy, plain toed shoes, I’ve had them for several months now and they’ve held up very well fit as well and I like the casual style. I’m gonna buy another pair just in case he’s wear out soon.

This is my second pair over the years of this exact same style. JM is quality and comfort in everything they do. These are a simple, smooth design that are easy to wear and go with everything. It’s like that nice pair of jeans you can dress up or down, throw these with no shoes and shorts or khakis and a sweater… done. A must have for the closet.

This is my third pair of this exact shoe. Comfortable, what I need for a desk job where I do walk around some. First two were purchased at a brick and mortar store (quality was good, wore them till I wore through the sole), this pair from Amazon. I don't know if I got a knockoff or if the quality has just been going down over the years, but from the first times I bent down to look at something (flexing the shoe around the ball of my foot) they started to separate at the sides. 6 months in, this is where they are at now. Will be looking at different brands in the future.

Love them

leather is a little lighter and the white sole is more tan...I am happyThey will scuff easily.

Well-made shoes and comfortable. I was looking for an alternative to my boat shoes.