Mommy Makeup Waterproof Stay Put Gel Eyeliner Pot with Micropigments - Smudge-Proof, Long Lasting, Highly Pigmented Cream Eye Liner, 0.14 oz (Olive It Up)

I rarely rate beauty products because I’m usually disappointed and I don’t like leaving terrible reviews. Thankfully, this eyeliner delivers perfection. I am 60, with blue eyes. I ordered the Steel Gray b/c I wanted something less severe than Black. My complexion is rather fair, especially in the winter. This is the best eyeliner I have used in forever. I prefer it over all of my high end products. It goes on so smoothly and it’s very easy to get it right. It’s highly pigmented so remember that when you dip your brush. A little goes a long way. I found this much easier to apply than any pencil or liquid liner. I use it on my upper lid and just a tiny bit along the outer edge of my bottom lashes. It didn't budge once dry. Absolutely give this a try! Def use a good brush to apply.

I have struggled with eyeliner for years and have tried everything- liquid, pencils, gel pencils, from drug store to high end brands. FINALLY, I found an eyeliner that is easy to apply, stays in place and really frames my eyes. I have always used black but tried the green and found it to be less harsh than black and a good compliment to my hazel eyes. Buy a good brush to apply this with. You may think the little container doesn't contain much product, but you don't need to use a lot. I am almost 70 and my eyelids are a little bit wrinkled, but I can get really close to the lash line with no skips for a very natural, seamless look. You won't regret buying this product!

I ordered two of these. Should have tried one first. Eyeliner was OFF within the first 4-6 hours. I requested a refund which was granted. I even got a text from Amazon stating i didn't need to return the items but a full refund would be granted. Three weeks later i had to escalate a complaint and Amazon rep says the "SELLER" has not issued my return. Really? So if I didn't keep track they would have just kept my $45 for nothing? Very reputable especially with the name "Mommy Makeup." Go elsewhere to save yourself time and hassle for a no good product

I’ve been trying different green makeup to enhance the hazel in my eye color. This is a creamy, easy to apply dark green liner. I like it, no smearing- it stays in place all day. It doesn’t look “green” a few feet away - I have to look very close in a mirror to see it’s green. It does exactly what I want - enhance my eye color. It hasn’t created any irritation to my eyes. It cleans off as easily as much more expensive gel liners and the consistency of the gel so far is the same as more expensive liners I normally use. I’ve only had it a short while and can’t address if it dries out quickly as some do.

Love this product. Goes on great and comes off easy with eye remover.

I really wanted to love this, and I do really like it for very natural makeup days, but it's not what I hoped for. The consistency is very soft, almost like a jelly. It makes it very hard to make a thin line because the brush picks up so much product due to it being so pudding-like. When I apply it, it's basically a wash of color. It tints my lash line but isn't a noticeable line. It's very natural and just makes my upper lash line a shade or two darker. I was hoping for a solid line of liner. It might be because it is so metallic, maybe it's reflecting the light too much to be visible among my lashes? Don't know. It does stay wonderfully with no smudging or fallout. Picture of the Mommy Makeup on the top and Sephora's brown (which is more of a warm black IMO) gel liner on the bottom.

This eyeliner is beautiful and it feels incredible to wear!! Living in the south can be a challenge for makeup durability, but not with the Mommy Makeup eyeliners. The eyeliner goes on silky-smooth and does not smudge or clump, even in 90 degree weather. I have used both the Mommy Makeup pointed eyeliner brush and the angled eyeliner brush to apply the liner and both brushes work beautifully and clean easily. I prefer the angled brush for my eyelid and the pointed brush for an extremely smooth, precise lower lid. The eyeliners work excellent by themselves as well as with both cream and powder eyeshadows. They are also easy to remove at the end of the day woth most ake up removers (my go-to remover is Lumify Micellar makeup remover from Bausch + Lomb - Not affiliatedwith Mommy Makeup, but also avaliable on Amazon). I have sensitive skin, especially around my eyes and Mommy Makeup has not caused any skin irritation. The Mommy Makeup eyeliners are incredible and have already replaced my previous favorite eyeliner brands (M.A.C. and Bobbi Brown). Definitely check out the Mommy Makeup store on Amazon or their actual webstore for excellent makeup selections in addition to their eyeliners. Mommy Makeup has fantastic customer service! **I am a real customer and I have NOT paid for my review.**

I really like this cream eyeliner. The color is wonderful. I use a special applicator and it glides on like butter. There is even a hint of sparkle! I will buy more.

I have to be careful with eye make up because of wearing contact lenses, but this works really well. It goes on easily, doesn't smudge and doesn't get in my eyes. I'm happy, and so are my contact lenses :) Even better that it doesn't have paragons etc in it. Great product.

As an eyeliner