Jillian Dempsey Khol Eyeliner: Clean, Waterproof Eyeliner Pencil with Built-In Smudger for Effortless Blending – Rich Pigment, Cruelty-Free?, Rich Brown

UPDATE: This eyeliner works great for blending into the eyelid as a creamy shadow and as a light smudged eyeliner. Does not irritate the eyes. Works better using a small sponge-like smudger or the finger. The included smudger doesn't work good. Original review: Four stars for good ingredients and color. If you try to use it as a defined eyeliner it doesn't stay in place, smudges too easily, the tip is too soft and keeps breaking, application is hard to get precise. it does glide on smooth to prevent pulling the skni. But the included smudger pulls the skin too much and makes the eyeliner messy.

glides on ok usually good but sometimes can be patchy for some reason along waterline. hard to blend and smudge out as victoria beckham. but one of my favorite everyday liners in brown. biggest issue is durability of packaging. unfortunately the caps will fall off or break or the pencil will before you finish it. appreciate the blender though but its not super good quality so doesnt blend great.

Best eyeliner ever

I have sensitive eyes and for years I've looked for an eyeliner that doesn't irritate my eyes, is easy to use, and stays put all day. This is that eyeliner. For the first time in my life, I'm able to wear eyeliner every day because I know my eyes won't hurt. It glides on smoothly and I know it stays all day because I remove it with micellar water each night.

I really wanted to like this pencil. The color is nice and the product is creamy and feels good on the skin. Unfortunately for me the waterproof didn't work as advertised. I lined my upper eyelid and the color transferred to the skin below my eyes by end of day and from there is was harder to remove.