e.l.f. Liquid Eyeliner, High-pigment Liquid Eyeliner With Extra-Fine Brush Tip, Easy Glide Smudge-proof Formula, Charcoal

Literally the only eyeliner I will ever buy, it is so cheap and lasts 8+ hours. I clean for a living, so naturally I move and sweat a lot- this eyeliner doesn’t budge or flake. The color is a nice deep black and has the perfect brush for getting a precise wing. Can’t recommend it enough 🩷

I finally found a liquid eyeliner that doesn't fade off during the course of the day. I can wear it for 8 - 10 hours with no flake off. Easy smooth application which dries quickly. Very easy to take off with makeup remover at end of day. I bought black and it's not a heavy looking black.

I love using elf products and it having two for the price can't pass the deal

It works great. What I do not like is the shine. I prefer my eyeliner to dry matte. I also wish the brush to would be a bit thicker or would carry more product.Today rained all day and I ran errands. The pictures are after my day is done. It stayed put and didn't run. That's really good to me. The price is also really good. But I will not purchase again because it's shiny. To me, cheap eyeliner is shiny, like we white in the 90s. So yes, I know it's cheap. But I don't want to look that way. Lol so it did good for errands but I won't wear this on a night out.

Favorite cheap eyeliner. Smudges a bit throughout the day but I feel that’s more my eye shape than just the makeup.

I will use this eyeliner for the rest of my life. It dries quickly, is easy to use, stays on all day, and is very pigmented.

Fiance loves this stuff

Good eyeliner hard to get off and it’s smudges if you have oily to normal skin. But the precision is really good!