2 NYX Jumbo Eye Pencil - Set (604,601)Milk,Black Bean

I wanted the jumbo pencil in milk for a long time because I've always heard such rave reviews about it and without having any luck finding it in stores anywhere I decided to try amazon and WOW these are my new must-haves. I love using Milk on my waterline and inner corners to make my eyes look wider and really pop. I forgot that it came with Black Bean as well, and at first I was a little worried I wouldn't be able to find a use for it but I tried it out on my waterline and it's amazing. I've always had a hard time doing liner on my waterline but this is easy, I think because it's so big. The pigments are great and it goes on smooth. Kind of has a creamy texture but haven't noticed any creasing. I can't tell you how much I love these, they've instantly become staples for my makeup collection.

I decided to purchase these after watching tons of reviews on YouTube and I must say that I am quite impressed. I wanted to get the black bean because I knew that it would be a get great base for a smoky eye and milk really helps to intensify any color that you are going to put on your lid. I apply my primer, apply the base (pencil) on top (blending it out), and then apply my eyeshadow. As you can see in the pictures the eyeshadows showed significantly more with the milk jumbo pencil as a base. For those of you who are wondering how to sharpen them. All you need to do is put them in the freezer for about 15 minutes and then sharpen them with a sharpener that has a large size for the pencil. I am so glad I now have these because they are going to take my eyeshadow skills to another level!If you found my review helpful will you please let me know by clicking that underneath my comment. Thank you!

The color doesn't stay on my eyes/eyelid. It smudged easily. If you itch your eyes/eyelid, the product easily gets on your finger and in your nails.You need to apply it on a couple of times to get the color. When sharpen, the whole tip piece breaks off and sticks inside the sharpener and you have to sharpen it again and again (it gets very messy because the texture is like soft, smushy wax). The plastic clear cap crack the second time I cap it back on the pencil. To me, it's trash. I'm a makeup artist and I have used way better eye pencils then this one.

I can't get enough of these pencils. No matter what color I put on my eyes, I will put this underneath the powder. It makes everything bold and amazingly bright. They don't last very long, if you are like me and change your own makeup twice a day, and do other peoples' makeup as well, but the quality is so wonderful that it doesn't matter.They are a little expensive for what you use them for, but when compared to similar products, it is not really a big deal. I would rather pay a little more for these, than have a crappy substitute.Pro Tip: Use the "Milk" color under any bright eyeshadows. It will intensify any colors.

I gave this a 4 star rating because it really creases on your eyelids! You have to have a primer and even then it creases slighty. I like that it is smooth and creamy though. I love the milky white color. I have not tried the black one because of the creasing of the white one. It creased about 1-2 hours after I applied. I will keep playing with this product to see if I can get it to not crease. Maybe if I apply less product to the lids. I do like it for inner eye highlight.

This goes on very smoothly, but has not worn down quickly either. It goes on effortlessly on the wetline, unlike many pencils that skip. I line my eyes with the black, really no need to even smudge, then smudge the white on as a light eyeshadow. I like it just to brighten my lid, so that is why I just smudge a little on, but it does go on very white and opaque if that was what you were looking for. Then I do a light dust of powder all over, and thats it. I think these are some of my favorite.

I've heard a lot about the jumbo eye pencils from NYX and decided to finally check them out for myself.As a professional Makeup Artist, I am always on the hunt for versatile product. NYX Jumbo Eye Pencil is just that! It has great color pay off and smooth consistency. Milk can be used as a highlight, (under brow, top of cheek bone and down the nose). What I really love about Milk is using it as an eyeshadow base, especially when using bright shadow. Black Bean can be used the same, as a base on the lid before dark smoky eye, or liner. I would recommend getting this product WITH the NYX pencil sharpener (it has a side that will fit these pencils). Love and will purchase again when I run out.

I have been looking for thicker eye pencil .This one is great .but it smudges so bad !!!!Everytime i used it it smudges all over the eye . After an hour of application , i look like a crazy person on loose !!