Temptations MixUps Surfers' Delight flavor treats for cats, Pack of 10

My cat loves it

Cat does not like it.

It's good. My kitty loves it.. but tooooo expensive.

Great value & my kitty loves them!

I bought four of the 16oz containers, because the sale they were on made them even cheaper per ounce than the bulk bags that I usually buy. All three of my cats do like these treats. They still seam to favor the salmon and tuna flavors, but that's obviously going to be different for every cat. The price point really was good and made it so that I got 16 additional ounces for only a couple more dollars compared to when I buy them in the 48oz bags. The only problem I had was the condition of the containers when they arrived. All four containers came with their lids popped off. Three of them had the inner seals broken open. One of those three containers was also crushed to the point that it was no longer usable. There were treats spilled throughout the box that had many other items in it as well. I took everything else out and put as many treats as I could fit back into the two open, non-broken containers. My cat's sat by and happily helped me by eating some of the treats that I gave them while I worked. They were a big help in reducing the amount that needed to be repackaged ;^D . I put the rest of the loose ones and the the ones still inside of the crushed container (I was EXTREMELY careful not to get any of the broken plastic pieces in with the treats) into an old temptations container that I had. I realize it's not a big deal in the scheme of things, and I'm still giving five stars, because the price point was great, and my cats still enjoy them. Having to do a few minutes of clean up to save that much money is worth it to me in this economy. I was just confused as to why there weren't external seals around the edges of the lids. Every time that I have ever purchased Temptations in the plastic containers they have had the lids sealed properly. Maybe that's why they were so cheap (???). I just want to let people know that they may have a small clean up situation when these treats arrive. I also want to recommend to the seller or warehouse workers that it might be a good idea to tape the lids down on these. I know that you are already overworked and stressed, but, if possible, it would be a quick solution to a shipping issue that many people would appreciate (Thank you for everything that you do!). Overall, they were worth the savings, and I survived the clean up process unscathed! My cat's also thank you for the yummy treats!