Honest Beauty Longlasting Liquid Eyeliner | Smudge + Flake Proof, Precise Application | Hypoallergenic, Vegan, + Cruelty Free | Black, 0.58 fl oz

Healthy option! Been using for years. The lengthening side is great also. Mascara goes on with ease, no clumps, easy to remove. Just don't go watch a sad romcom cause it ain't waterproof 😉 Why would you want toxins on your eyeballs!?

I really like this eye liner knowing that it is cruelty free, it comes off so easy with water. I just wish they made a dark brown.

Purchased this as it is one of the liquid liners that has clean ingredients. It has a matte finish, which I really love. I’m also able to do a good wing line with it, which can be hard with certain liner brushes but this one does just fine! My only issue is that it definitely rubs off/easily smudges. Any sweat, heat, etc. will cause it to smudge.But overall, this is the best clean ingredient liner I’ve found!

Very natural plant, derived, non-irritating eyeliner. I thought I had to give up eyeliner forever until I found this!

This liner is perfect for getting that sharp wing, but it does smear if it gets a bit wet like from your eyes tearing or even applying setting spray. So it’s a bit of a small thing to get passed

The media could not be loaded. Never buying any other mascara again!!! 😍 It’s so good! It doesn’t clump, and the primer makes it apply so nicely and builds so much volume without looking thick! I’ve NEVER felt comfortable just wearing mascara out, but I went out with just this today and felt so cute! It’s super comfortable and I don’t even notice that I have it on. I’ve had it on all day at the time I’m taking these pictures and leaving this review and I can confidently say I love it and highly recommend it!!! It makes my lashes look so long and dark and the applicator is PERFECT for close application without getting it all over my eyelids (which is usually my problem lol)

Wanted to make the switch to a cleaner eyeliner but this was not it! First off the box nor the actual eyeliner was sealed. It didn’t look used so I tried it. It seemed to go on fine but it did smudge a bit. At the end of the day I removed it with water (that’s how easily it comes off) and immediately my eyes became extremely itchy. Next thing I know my eyelids are red from all the irritation. I must have had some sort of allergic reaction. Definitely disappointing.

I have used eyeliner pens for years. I was nervous to try a liquid eyeliner because I thought it would be difficult to apply. I am happy to report that I was mistaken - this liquid eyeliner is way easier to use that the pens I’ve been using for ten years. I only regret that it took me so long to make the switch. My only complaint is that it smears easily when my eyes tear up or water. I know it’s not supposed to be waterproof, but it doesn’t last as long as other non waterproof eyeliners. I don’t mind it though because I can easily wipe off the smudged part and reapply.