CLIO Sharp So Simple Waterproof Pencil Eye Liner | Micro Precision Tip (2mm), Twist Up, Self-Sharpening, Long Lasting, Smudge-Resistant, High-Intensity Color, Ultra-Smooth | Dark Brown (#5)

Great product. I use it to tightline and it does not transfer and has staying power. BUT! the product ran out in less than 6 weeks. I only applied it once daily. I expected double the time. I just bought a Milani Stay Put liner to replace the Clio and it's ok. It will transfer a bit. The Ulta waterproof pencil is also a good value. I like the Clio best, though, and guess I need to just buy two at a time.

Really waterproof and doesn’t smudge

I bought this in brown after watching a review on YouTube, so obviously had to try it, as I’ve bought many eyeliners in the past that have Promised longevity, being waterproof & smudge free, that have all failed miserably. I also have very sensitive eyes & can react quite severely to certain brands.On my first try, it took a while to get the colour on to my upper waterline, but once I swiped it on the back of my hand, I found it released more colour. I’m in my late 50’s and have developed dry eyes, my left eye is watering all the time, so I didn’t think it would grip the colour without it making its way down my face. How wrong was I! It was applied at 10am & still on at 10pm, slightly fainter, but definitely still on my waterline & wasn’t appearing in any creases or under eye area. I washed my face using a cleanser & muslin cloth, it was still there, so used Nivea waterproof eye makeup remover, which worked a treat.I couldn’t recommend this eyeliner enough, for price, quality, longevity & no sensitivity to this product.

If you’re looking for a smudge proof everyday liner, it’s for you. I wear it working out and doesn’t smudge at all. No panda eyes! Very good and easy to apply as it’s smooth!!

I liked the colour, but the pen was not comfortable to write with. The lead is thick and hard to write with.