Lord & Berry SMUDGEPROOF Eye Liner - Soft & Creamy VEGAN Formula, Long Lasting Morning to Night Waterproof Eyeliner Pencil, Easy to Use Eye Makeup

I love this eyeliner. I've only found one other that is comparable. I also have less eye irritation with this longer and it's easy to blend. Good product!

Goes on smoothly, stays put without smudging and comes off easily....great product! LOVE IT!

I have been a longtime user of all MAC cosmetic products for 20+ years, including their eyeliner. However over the last few years they discontinued one of the eyeliners I was regularly buying, and I switched to another one of their eyeliners that I thought would be comparable. Unfortunately that new one was a complete flop and smudged a lot and I looked terrible midway through the day (like I had been crying!). I have previously also used other eyeliners from other well-known brands and always found the pencils to be too hard and have not applied smoothly. With the new MAC eyeliner that I started using, it would go on smoothly but would sadly completely smudge. So I was on the hunt (again!) for a great eyeliner and found Lord & Berry and thought I would give it a try. The reviews are true and this eyeliner, as the description accurately notes, DOES NOT smudge! AND it goes on smoothly and STAYS on! The quality is fantastic and I am very happy. The only caveat is I have not had to sharpen the pencil yet and am not sure if the quality of the pencil will decline after doing that (fingers crossed that it doesn't!). For now I am confidently giving it a 5 out of 5 - for the strength of the product and the reasonable price!

Finally, a great eye liner. It's staying all day without coming off.

The liner itself worked well. The problem with the pencil was sharpening it. It didn't last very long, very hard to sharpen.

I love it. It does not smudge like some of the others do. It last all day and stays where it belongs. Will buy again.

Bought this awhile ago looking for smudge proof eyeliner since apparently end of the day I looked like a raccoon. Paid more than I wanted for this item but it had good reviews. I wouldn't recommend it - for me at least it didnt deliver. It still smudged after a couple of hours. Found Loreal to be more reliable recently and less expensive too. At the end of the day (more hours than Lord&Berry lasted) and I don't look like a raccoon..if anything the Loreal smudge proof pencil just kind of disappears after 10 hours but it doesn't smudge. Save yourself some dollars and go with Loreal or even Covergirl

I love this brand. This liner actually stays on my waterline. It is a bit softer than the liners that I've gotten from them in the past, so I have to sharpen it more frequently, but I think the soft texture is what makes it last longer.Even if it does fade a bit from the waterline, it clings to the base of my lashes in a way that still gives the appearance of a subtle liner. I can be a little tough to Fully remove, but I love it and will absolutely by again.