DC-BEAUTIFUL18 Colors Lip Liners Pencil Set with 2 Pencil Sharpeners, Premium Waterproof Smooth Lip Pencils, Long Lasting Matte Makeup Lipliners

Why did you pick this product vs others?:Great price for a nice variety of colors. I love that they're old-school pencil style, and come with a sharpener.

I purchased both style-1 and style-2. Both arrived well-packaged and undamaged. The included sharpeners are a nice touch. They go on smoothly, for the most part. Some are better than others and I cannot pinpoint why the difference. I have had better lip liners (smoother, better color saturation) but, as with most things, price usually dictates quality. I did not have super high expectations for these and I am not disappointed. One thing I noted is that while all of them are marked with the color number, only the pencils from style-2 also have the color name on them. Of course, this is not a big deal, just...odd. I use alone (no lipstick) with a clear gloss over them and they work well for my needs. Overall this is a good price for a very good selection of colors.

Many different colors....

Box came open They lids were off and some were broken but great colors.

great to have all these choices...and they are good pencils that last!

Item arrived promptly and intact, new and unused in box, I am a makeup connoisseur and I can tell you these lip liners are freaking AWFUL- waxy, hard, pointy and painful and they pull on your skin and lips when applying. I don't understand all the positive reviews, either I got a REALLY bad batch, or the reviewers are new to using lip liners and don't know that there ARE super creamy, much better quality lip liners to be had. The texture on these which are made by PUDALIER were somewhere between that of a crayon and an actual old-school wooden, colored ART pencil. It wasn't a temperature issue. When warmed they were just as bad. It came with a tiny pencil sharpener which gives the pencils the same small factory sharpened point, which in any brand new lip pencil I immediately sharpen to get rid of; I used my own sharpener to give a bigger point wondering if the factory point was the issue so there was a longer,wider point on the liner, but they still were hard and waxy and pulled with minimal color depositing on the lips unless you pressed firmly. If you want to use them to draw on your ARM to check the color, guess what? They are still waxy and hard. They are made in China and there were a couple of funny things- one shade was called "P is for Danger", bwahahaha, I reckon the letter P looks like a D, and there is a pencil that named "Lady Danger" which is a color dupe for MAC Cosmetics lipstick Lady Danger. Too bad the pencils SUCK!Do yourself a favor, and here on Amazon- treat yourself to the 12 PIECE ITALIA LIP LINER set which is fantastic! Or REALLY treat yourself to the awesome, longer pencil 54 PIECE NABI LIP LINER set-they ROCK and have plenty of wearable colors in both warm and cool shades. Both brands are creamy, gentle on your lips, and have the same quality as MAC cosmetics lip liners, both of those sets to have some color dupes for MAC- and the reds are stunning!

I like the different shades of pinks, reds, and purples. Awesome for me because I bought a lipstick online and when I got it, I hated the color. With these lipliners, I can color in my lips making my lipstick pop!

The colors are very light. You’re not going to get a heavy line. Can’t see the line on lips. I wouldn’t purchase again.