stila Waterproof Liquid Eye Liner, Stay All Day Makeup with Fine Brush Tip Lasting Satin Finish, Smudge-Proof & Transfer-Resistant

I was looking for a new liquid eyeliner, as the one I had used before doubled in price. I read countless reviews and suggestions which led me to the NYX Epic eyeliner as it was said to not budge and be hard to take off. BUT it smeared instantly on me! So I went back to reviews and tried this Stila one and... the positive reviews are legit! I live in a very wet/humid/sweaty climate and sweat easily, and this stuff didn't budge AT ALL. I wore it for 9 hours, even as sweaty as I was, and wiped the liner with my finger, and it still didn't move nor did it transfer to any other part of my eye area (looking at you, NYX). I didn't use any primers beforehand. Just pure Stila eyeliner! This will be a staple in my makeup routine now.

I love this eyeliner! It is a nice, dark black. I am a sweaty girl and this eyeliner for the most part stays put. Under my wings, I may need to clean up a tiny bit after the whole day, but the liner itself doesn't remove from where you placed it. I have been getting this eyeliner for years, definitely my go to!

For all my fellow hooded eye Asians, this is it. This is the one. Precise, black, and smooth to apply. Not only do I have hooded eyes, but I also have oily eyelids and this can last all day for me - with foundation and setting powder underneath. I have tried many different eyeliners and nothing compares to Stila for me.I have re-ordered this 31 times at the time of my review. So my obsession is real.

I love this eyeliner. It’s bold, it stays put, and it makes me feel like I still know what I’m doing with makeup — even if my face occasionally disagrees.I knocked off one star because it’s not perfectly smooth to apply... but honestly, that might be less about the product and more about the topographical map that is my eyelids these days. Gravity has done some creative things up there.All in all, it’s a fantastic eyeliner. If you’re under 40, it might glide like a dream. If you’re over 50 (plus) like me, just give it a second to dry, lean in close, and call it art. 🖌️💁‍♀️Highly recommend — and if it came with a wrinkle-smoothing setting, I’d give it six stars.

Love this eyeliner! It makes smooth, fine, even strokes. Glides on easy. The color is exactly as described. It is waterproof and lasted all day, even on my water line. Will purchase again!

I have tried many liquid eyeliners, this is a great one. I bought the grey because I wanted a softer and cooler toned liner than black. The pen is very fluid and glides on my eyelids very well. The ink doesn’t bleed into my 48 year old skin cracks. For comparison, in the picture, the Stilla grey is on the bottom, top is “zero” black from urban decay.

Maybe I'm doing something wrong? I read such great reviews of this, so I got one. I always have primer on my lids, as they tend to get oily throughout the day, and then I apply any eyeshadow or liner afterward. This stuff only lasts maybe 4 hours, then it starts to disappear.I do like how smoothly it goes on and how quick it dries... everything else about it. So I'll give it a few more chances. But so far it's not staying as long as I'd like.

Best liquid eyeliner I have ever used. Super precise application. This is coming from a girly who can live without her eyelid wings. Totally worth the almost 30$