WD My Book Studio II - 2 TB (2 x 1 TB) USB 2.0/FireWire 800/eSATA Desktop External Hard Drive

[Updated this review on 28-Jun-2011]I have purchased 4 of these Western Digital Studio II external hard drives over the past 18 months (three of them are 4TB, one of them is 6TB), and they are great. The first 3 of these I bought have been chugging along with constant use for more than a year, with nary a hiccup. I just purchased the 6TB model about a week ago, and it looks identical to the 4TB models -- I have high hopes for it as well.For some context: In the past, I purchased 2 Iomega external drives and 4 LaCie external drives, and ALL of those external drives completely failed after a few months of use, while connected to 3 different computers. Unbelievable! But these Western Digital Studio II drives are a dream. They keep going and going...These Western Digital Studio II drives have a choice of 4 different interfaces (USB 2.0, FireWire 400, FireWire 800, and eSATA), and I've used them with all of the interfaces. I've also used them on Windows Vista and Windows 7 (both 32-bit and 64-bit), on three different computers. No matter which interface you use, or which version of Windows, they work right out of the box, are immediately recognized by Windows, no drivers needed. No fuss, no bother, no reading the user manual, etc. (You just need to remember to format the drive for Windows; see below.)Over the past 18 months or so, I have discovered some technical tidbits about using these drives that I wanted to pass along, because it might help someone who is stuck. Most of this information applies to any large external drive that you attach to a Windows computer; this info is not necessarily specific to these Western Digital drives.So, here are some technical tips when using these Western Digital My Book Studio II drives:1. When you receive the drive, it is formatted for the Mac, rather than Windows. No problem, you just need to format it for Windows, which takes less than a minute. IMPORTANT: When you are formatting the drive for Windows, you MUST use the USB 2.0 port on the drive (with a USB 2.0 cable -- included with the drive) to format it. After that, you can use any of the interfaces (USB 2.0, FireWire 400 or 800, or eSATA) to access the drive. If you try to format the drive while connected to your computer with eSATA, your computer will only see about half of the drive's capacity. Again, this only affects initial formatting. After formatting, use any interface, and your computer will see the full capacity of the drive. HOW TO FORMAT: Choose Start, right-click on Computer, choose Manage, and select Disk Management. You probably know the drill from there, but if not, see the documentation that comes with the drive. Do a "Quick Format" -- no need to do the lengthy normal format.2. The fastest port on these drives is the 3Gbit/sec eSATA port. If you only have one eSATA port on your computer, and you have more than one of these drives (like me), you might think you can use an eSATA external port multiplier to turn your one eSATA port on your computer into multiple eSATA ports so you can connect multiple external drives to one eSATA port on your computer. However, this only works if the eSATA port on your computer supports an eSATA port multiplier. Some computer eSATA ports do not (for example, I have a Dell XPS 17 laptop, and its eSATA port does not support an eSATA port multiplier). If you are in this situation, or if you don't have any eSATA ports at all on your computer, but you DO have a USB 3.0 or SuperSpeed USB 3.0 port on your computer, you are golden. You can use a StarTech.com USB3S2ESATA 3 Feet SuperSpeed USB 3.0 to eSATA Cable Adapter or similar product, which is a USB 3.0 to eSATA adapter cable, to connect the eSATA port on your external drive to the USB 3.0 port on your computer. Most USB 3.0 ports run at 5Gbit/sec, and even though most eSATA ports only run at 3Gbit/sec, this adapter cable lets you use the drive at 3Gbit/sec from your computer's USB 3.0 port, which is 6 times faster than the slow 480Mbit/sec speed of a USB 2.0 port connection.3. I discovered, on my computer, that when I attached one of these drives to my laptop computer via my computer's eSATA port, that my computer would no longer reboot successfully, unless I unplugged the eSATA cable and plugged it back in after my computer got past the initial stages of rebooting. This is not the fault of the drive. As noted on the Western Digital knowledge base on their web site, the BIOS of many computers cannot recognize hard drives larger than 2TB (even though Windows Vista and Windows 7 can recognize much larger drives), so the BIOS stops rebooting when it sees my huge 4TB or 6TB drive plugged into the eSATA port on my computer. I rebooted my computer and pressed F12 to change the "Boot Order" on my computer, but there was no way to tell the BIOS NOT to look at the eSATA port when rebooting. However, my computer BIOS DOES let me tell it to ignore the USB 3.0 ports on my computer when booting. So, I plugged my 6TB (or 4TB) drive into my computer's USB 3.0 port, using the above USB 3.0 to eSATA adapter cable to connect to the drive's eSATA port, and told the BIOS boot order on my computer to ignore the USB ports, and now my computer reboots fine when my big Western Digital 4TB and 6TB drives are plugged into it. Plus, it still has 3Gbit/sec transfer speed, which is great.4. With Windows 7 (and perhaps with all versions of Windows and Macs, I'm not sure), these external drives will go to "sleep" after somewhere around 15-30 minutes of inactivity. In theory, this is not a problem, because the next time you try to access the drive from Windows, the drive will automatically spin up, and about 10-15 seconds later it will respond as normal. However, it takes sufficiently long for the drive to "awaken" from sleep that Windows 7 sometimes records the drive as no longer available, until you unplug and re-plug the power to the external drive. There is a little bit of discussion about this problem on the Internet. No one seems completely certain why the drive goes to sleep (is the it the firmware in the drive, or is it a "sleep" command from Windows 7?) and there does not seem to be a consensus on how to solve it -- different people offer different solutions. However, I wanted to share the solution that I found for this problem, if you are using the external drive via the USB port (or via the drive's eSATA port going to a USB 3.0 port on your computer using a USB 3.0-to-eSATA adapter): Under Windows 7, go into the Control Panel. At the top right of the screen, choose "View by: Small icons." Click on "Power Options." Look at which "power plan" you have selected (that has the radio button selected), and click the "Change plan settings" to the right of that. On the next screen, click on the "Change advanced power settings" link, toward the bottom. In the next dialog box, scroll down and click the "+" next to "USB settings." Then, beneath that, click the "+" next to "USB selective suspend setting." Change the "Plugged in" setting to be "Disabled," and if you also use these external drives on battery power, change the "On battery" setting to also be "Disabled." Then, click OK to close the dialog box. Making this change to the Power Options under Windows 7 seems to prevent Windows 7 from putting the external drives to sleep. Alternatively, other people have had success using a free utility called "xSleep" at [...]that periodically accesses your external drives so they won't go to sleep under any version of Windows (and you can put it on a schedule, so the drives can go to sleep at night, for example).I hope the above info is helpful to someone. These Western Digital My Book Studio II drives are awesome.

Just got my My Book Studio II for my iMac. I went through the hassle of upgrading my own iMac, pulling open the case, taking the screws out, and pulling up the LCD screen, to replace the measly 350GB drive with 1.5TB drive, but still over time I got so many files in there that yesterday I had less than 300GB free space on the drive and thing have been slowing down. It was time, past due, for a change, some kind of upgrade.I tried the G-RAID box, and it was fairly fast, and it looked nice ... aluminum, with styling like my the Mac so I went with it first, but it made way way too much noise. So, I did some reading and found the WD My Book Studio II. I had owned another plastic box enclosure like this that looked similar that did not open up had I wanted to upgrade the enclosure with newer bigger drives, but SURPRISE, the WDMBSII is upgradeable by the user. To be sure, you void the warranty if you do that, but being user upgradeable is a big plus for me. I cannot use something too small with a useless warranty compared to something that works without a warranty anyway, so at some point in the future if I need to I can EASILY upgrade the drives in the WDMBSII.So, I loaded the RAID manager software because I wanted to reconfigure the device to be RAID1 (it comes configured as RAID0/striping out of the box) - that is, to duplicate all data on both drives so it is redundant and I will not lose any data if a drives dies. Then I plugged the drive in, connected it via the FW800 port on my Mac and voila ! ! ! it worked like a charm.It was hard to tell if it was really on, except for the light that bounces around on the front panel to tell you that it is on and accessing data. This drive is absolutely dead silent. If you put your hand on the drive itself you can feel it is slightly warm if it has been on for a while, and there is a slight vibration from the platters rotating inside the drives, but I cannot feel by touching my desk and I cannot hear it even though it is maybe 2 and a half feet away right on my desk. I love it!So, the next thing I did was set up the move of my data ... about a TB of movies, music and media. Some of it had to move via the iTunes problem within its internal management, so was a bit slower, but it transferred overnight with no problem. The hardest thing to do, was an Apple problem, to figure out how to move data that OSX thinks needs to be in some particular place by design and does not want the user to mess with, but I took care of that.I am positively amazed and blown away by how nice this product is ... almost as much as I was with the iMac itself, because it also has no fans and is dead silent. What a great working environment, with 2TB of REDUNDANT working space right on my desktop ... something that would have been unthinkable not very long ago I am now set to do anything on my iMac that I want to for the immediate future.The only question I still have is, how reliable is the box and the disk drives? I have had very few failures with external boxes in the past. I've been a little iffy on Western Digital drives, but Apple uses WD drives inside their system, so any problems WD has had from the old days seem to be solved now. I had no real reason to be nervous, so I'll just wait and see and let you know by updating this review if anything goes wrong.Until I do have a problem ... I have to say the WDMBSII is batting 1000% and I am very happy to have found it, and pleased to have bought it, it is perfect for home/desk/office/multimedia use. The footprint is small, the box is kind of cute with the white LED power light that rocks up and down when the disk is being accessed, and it is very fast ... but most of all it is beautifully silent! YEAH Western Digitial, you hit it out of the park here! Thank you, great job!

I had planned on writing something much more Shakespearian in style (hence the title), but I1. haven't had enough coffee this morning to write something good2. frankly, I don't think I could write something good3. I'm feeling rather meta today so....I needed a near line storage solution, resilient in the RAID 1 manner to attach to a mid 2010 mac mini media server. While the house is not only mac hardware, most media is. FW800 is the fastest the mini supported and it needed large space (>2TB) and reliability AND user upgradability. There were precious few solutions.Installation was easy, except for having to use an actual CD to install the little application. Why don't people just put a little USB drive instead? Also, why should I have to install an app? Can't I just manage it with existing OS tools?Only thing I didn't like is it was set at RAID 0 not RAID 1 out of the box. Install app, plug in, and go. Decent speed for that generation, quiet, rather undramatic in all.1.2 TB into restore and it is running like a champ. It has the features, does what it says and is very very stable. So far.If you're looking for that combo of features + a rather undramatic solution that is the same color as your mac, this is the box for you.