The Prophet and the Age of the Caliphates: The Islamic Near East from the 6th to the 11th Century (A History of the Near East)
C**O
the best book on the formation of islam
yeah ok it was a little hard going in bits but the info in this book is great.it was well worth the effort. I could now happily argue with muslims about M. and his mates, their world and their lives.good stuff.
S**U
Four Stars
good. Well-preserved.
M**N
Dry but very worthy
This work is a very useful historical survey of the major political developments that marked the classical era of Islamicate civilisation. I found it a very useful companion to other works that concentrate upon the cultural, social and intellectual aspects of Muslim history for example the works of Ira Lapidus and Marshall G Hodgson. Although it is a specialist work it has a clear narrative structure which allows for a degree of comparative analysis between the different regions covered by the study. Whilst it might be true to describe it as being a little dry and academic I consider this to be a strength and would certainly prefer it over more populist works of narrative history for example Bernard Lewis and the sensationalist revisionist accounts propounded by writers such as Patricia Crone and Wilfred Madelung. He does not seek to make reductive connections between historical effects and essential psychological or cultural causes which is refreshing and only adds to its overall authorativeness. I would recommend it to any reader who is genuinely interested in understanding the complexity of early Islamic history and its hightly contested and ideological character.
S**H
A Good Introduction
This is the earliest chronologically of a series of surveys of Middle Eastern history, and as such suffers from a lack of verifiable sources, particularly for the tine of Muhammad. Despite this, Hugh Kennedy presents a credible account in the first two-thirds of his book of the context of the early 7th century, the birth of the Muslim states and its expansion under the early caliphs, and the rise and fall of the Umayyad and Abbasid caliphates. This section also includes a review of Muslim political structures and of the formation and development of Shi'ism. This part is very useful and has a good narrative structure, although a rather more analysis might have been helpful.The last third of the book is harder to read, as each of its five chapters deals with a particular region and it rather difficult to keep track of what is happening in different places at the same time. This and the absence of much on cultural developments are the only weaknesses in a book which is a very useful survey of early Islamic history.
R**C
Dry, and a little confusing
The Prophet and the Age of the Caliphates, is an attempt to chart the early history or the growth of Islam. A very interesting propostition and as relevant today as it ever has been, especially given the troubles in the middle east, this books should be of great help to anybody with an interest in this area of the world.However it is not. While detailed, the style of writing is very dry and can be very confusing at times. Names of people and Caliph's come and go with very little to actually tell you who they are or where they come from. The success of the early Arab/Muslim armies agains all opposition is not really explained, to paraphrase, they came, they saw, they conquered and thats all we know from this work.A decent attempt, but could have been so much more
A**R
Good read!
I bought this book for a graduate course in Islamic political thought. It was used as and introductory read. It provides a detailed overview of the life of the Prophet Mohammed, and follows into the golden age of Islam. It does a great job of using all sources from religious to making mention of various 'mythical' images or stories that surround the early days of Islam. I would recommend this book for all who want to gain a better understanding of the beginnings of Islam or the origins of political islamic thought.
D**E
Slightly beyond the basics, but still a good introduction.
Great book for a foundation in Islamic history. It can get quite confusing for a westerner, with the names and all, but once an understanding of the historical figures is reached, it becomes very clear and insightful.
D**R
Great seller! Informative book! VERY dry read...
I bought this book because it's the most highly-recommended English book on the Abbasid Caliphate. It's very informative! However, as you might expect from an academic book, it's fairly dry. This is not "pop history"! You'll need to keep a highlighter handy and consult the index frequently if you want to really grasp everything.
A**R
Islamic History
For a student of the religion and its history Kennedy does a superb job of helping people to objectively understand the spread of Islam and Muslims.
A**S
Has a huge negative bias against Islam and is incredibly ...
Has a huge negative bias against Islam and is incredibly inaccurate. Definitely do not buy this book if you want to learn the truth about Islam and its history. Trust me when I say the Western superiority and bigotry in this book is appalling
Trustpilot
1 month ago
2 weeks ago