Mally Beauty Evercolor Starlight Waterproof Eyeliner - Caribbean Sea - Smudge-Proof, Longwear, Creamy Gel - Sharpenable Eyeliner

It is one of the best eyeliners on the market!

I’ve been using Mally eyeliner for for years now. Stays put all day. Gives you time to smudge and then sets. I’ll continue to bye Mally

This is the BEST eyeliner I have ever had! It was originally given to me as a gift. Since then I have reordered this Mally stick. It has staying power and the color does not fade or easily come off! It is easy to apply and is forgiving of mistakes.

This pencil is not the automatic one. The seller disclosed that but I like the Mally eye products enough that I took a chance on the one that needs manual sharpening. Right out of the box during first use the tip of the pencil broke when I was barely using any pressure. I would gladly buy Mally's retractable eyeliner but not the one needing manual sharpening. However, that said, the quality of the Mally product is not the seller's issue, but the rather manufacture's.

this is my favorite eyeliner Beautiful colors goes on smooth, last all day and comes off easily with make up remover. Great seller, quick delivery.

I loved this product but due to no longer available I’ve had to switch products

I was excited to try these after seeing the colors. Until I got them.After paying almost $20 I would like to think the product I received was new. However, what I was sent was the eyeliner out of the smashed box that had both ends opened and sent in a zip lock bag. The end was worn down some like it had been used or swatched. And there was a hair with a hair follicle on the end when I first opened it. Which is gross.I ordered 4 different colors and I do not see myself using them. 😕

I love the texture, but it just falls off your face. That makes it easy to remove but at the same time after a couple of hours he will have raccoon eyes.