Crayon Liner and Smudge Brush - Dual-Ended Black Eyeliner Pencil with Built-In Smudging Tool - Creamy Formula for Precise or Smoky Eye Looks - Stocking Stuffers

Perfect eyeliner. Creamy enough to smudge and blend, but doesn't move once it sets. Lasts until you remove it .

It’s great!

Great liner but was looking for something that was smudge proof so that I don't have to worry about it streaking or smudging but sadly it looks like no matter what I apply to my face and eyes it still seems to smudge no matter how hard I try!!

This liner has good time to smudge and then dries down well. I wiped it several times and doesn’t move. It appears to have good staying power. I am going to wear it again all day and see how it holds up but so far it seems to be good stuff!

I unwrapped this and the eyeliner was already broken and just fell out of the top of the pencil casing! About 1 inch what a waste! DO NOT BUY!

The eyeliner broke in half as I was taking it out of the plastic container, a bit flimsy. I was still able to try it out using the ends. The eyeliner goes on smoothly and looks great; however, there is some smearing. I have watery eyes so it's not the best fit for me.

So happy with this product. It glides on. Very pigmented. Has a blending brush on the other end that works like a charm! Lasts all day.

This is a decently pigmented eyeliner and blends very easily, but even after 15 minutes, the liner never actually sets and you can easily smear it with your finger. Unsurprisingly, this makes the liner very short lived and not at all long wearing. I think to have any hope of making this wearable, you MUST set it with a shadow when you're done blending, otherwise, after the slightest bit of oil or sweat, this product is long gone.