New York Professional Slim Lip Pencil, Creamy Soft Lip Liner, Smooth Long-Lasting Rich Lip Color, Natural Lip Makeup, Water-Resistant Lip Crayon (Black)

Smooth and black, a good, normal makeup pencil. It's soft, possibly too soft sometimes as the lines aren't always clean (I use it both as liner for black lipstick and eyeliner). But it's nothing I can't easily clean up. I always choose real Pencils over plastic ones as you never know how much product you'll actually get when you can't see it. The Pencils last me forever!

I love how this lip liner delivers rich pigment while still looking natural. It glides on smoothly and helps me create both subtle daytime looks and bold, defined lips for a night out. Very essential in my routine!!!

The formula is excellent and richly smoothing, although this liner tends to bleed/run so perhaps with a bit more prep and prime it’ll be a better application. Although, coconut oil being the main emollient is a bit counterintuitive since it can easily help remove makeup from the skin. I think this soft pencil is great for filling in rather than defining and lining.

It is soft and applies very smooth. It does not last very long and i find the color to be more of a dark gray. It is moisturizing for a little bit then it becomes dry. It does not stand a chance against food or drink..

I’ve brought a lip liner pencil before & it was rough and it easily broke but this is very pigmented and soft and I really love it!!

I ordered the black lip liner since I like to occasionally wear black lipstick. Not everybody makes these in black. Just know that this is the type of lip pencil you have to sharpen every now and then. Just this one pencil is probably going to last me a long time. It's very nice.

I’ve never used lip liners before but I found this one easy to use. The black went on nicely and it could be wiped away with a little effort, which is nice because you can fix mistakes without too much hassle.

Nice application strong color