Epic Wear Metallic Liquid Liner, Long-Lasting Waterproof Eyeliner - Silver Metal

Loving this eyeliner though it comes with a slight learning curve (at least for me) due to the long handle. My previous liquid eyeliner had a shorter handle which was easier to manipulate around the eye area. But it's fine, everything's fine, and this is my new favorite waterproof liquid eyeliner! It will not run, smudge, flake or move in any way -which is important to me as I wear RGP contact lenses. Can't have eyeliner flaking off or crying off or being sneezed off or anything like that with my contacts! I'm completely assured though that this stuff WON'T MOVE. I'm so confident in fact that I even line the top lid UNDER my lashes, to close that gap, and no worries whatsoever. Makes a gorgeous cat eye. Highly recommend!

I’ve been using Nyx waterproof liquid eyeliner for years. It truly is waterproof. I’ve cried, gone swimming and taken showers with it still on. Remove is easy use an oil to clean it then regular face wash. My go to ones are the black and sapphire. I find the lighter colors like white and yellow have a slightly different application a little less smooth . If using a color like yellow I typically use the black as a base then put the yellow on top. They last a really long time! You should change them out based on the expiration date… but I haven’t had any issues.

I bought this eyeliner because I was running out of the one I typically use. I loved the handle for this one and figured it would be great for quick application before I went to work. I was looking for smudge proof because I work retail and quite often end up rubbing my eyes in a hurry forgetting I’m wearing makeup. When it arrived it game in a decent sized box. (Quite wasteful if you ask me) but anyway I applied it on my hand to see how long it took to dry down how matte and how smudge proof it was. It took only a little to dry down worked very well when itt came to application and even rubbing my hardest right after application. It was great!!! I left it on my hand and went about my day not thinking about it. I wore it to work the next day. And rubbed my eyes many times and the only thing that game off was my mascara and the pencil liner I had on my bottom lash. I had worked a very long shift and accidentally fell asleep with my makeup on. When I woke up the next morning and went to look at my makeup before work it was still there and still as sharp as it was right after application. When I got home after work I tried to take it off use it Garnier SkinActive Micellar cleaning water like I use for all my makeup. It would NOT come off. It barely budged. So I went and took a shower and it started to come up at the edges but the shape was still there. This eyeliner lasted 3 days before I sat down and scrubbed it off. And I had to scrub so hard. So if you don’t like getting up to do your makeup and wanna be able to wake up and go. This is the eyeliner to get. It is so unbelievably long lasting

First things first, this is a solidly good product. The formula is SUPER long lasting and can take an absolute beating. The first day I wore this, I laughed, cried, accidentally rubbed my eyes, went out in the rain, and effectively put it through almost everything an eyeliner can go through. So, I feel equipped to say that this eyeliner is waterproof and smudge proof. Also, when I took it off 14 hours after applying, there was zero cracking, smudging, or any real show of wear. Having said that, it also refused to budge with my micellar water that removes literally all of my other makeup (including very waterproof mascara) until I rubbed quite hard. I'll be trying some other makeup remover and coconut oil to see if either of those work better. I like a long lasting eyeliner, but I don't want to take it to the grave. Okay, now, that I've addressed the good, it's time to move on to the bad and the ugly. The only reason I purchased this eyeliner is because, to my dismay, NYX discontinued their Matte Liquid Liner. This was my holy grail eyeliner. I wore it nearly every day, and never found myself disappointed. I felt a strangely real sense of loss when I learned it was discontinued, and quite frankly, it still stings. But, I figured it would be close enough. I like NYX products overall, due to their quality, price point, and lack of animal testing, and I knew I wanted a liquid liner with a pot and brush versus a more modern pen applicator. So, this seemed perfect. And again, it's good. But if you're coming from using the Matte Liquid Liner, there are some major differences. First, as some other reviewers have mentioned, the brush is noticeably thicker than the brush with the Matte Liquid Liner. This means, if you're accustomed to the thinner brush, this one can make you feel a little ham-fisted with your application, and it can make it harder to get fine details. Along with the brush itself, the formula feels thicker. There's a certain viscosity to this eyeliner that the Matte Liquid Liner lacked. This adds to the increased difficulty to get precise lines and details. Having said that, it's a decent replacement, and a solid option for the price point.

had to reorder a new one since the one my bf got me was broken. it's very long-lasting and it's perfect for graphic eye liner or sharp looks

Used it for years. None that stays better on the market, I’ve tried most of them. I used to work in kitchens and my winged liner would still be perfectly intact at the end of every shift. Through sweat, crying in the walk-in coolers a few times, you name it. Only oil can make this baby even budge.

Lasts so long and I wear it while I work and sweat alot during and still it stays on. And my eyes water alot too yet it stays on. Only thing is I will say it takes a bit to dry fully and you'll need an oil cleanser that can break down water proof mascara to get it off.

This product is waterproof - so much so that you must use an oil-based remover or baby oil to get it off. Unfortunately it does not flow smoothly - it is the general consistency of paint combined with school glue so it skips and pulls while going on. It is so thick that it takes forever to set, so you accidentally smear it in unwanted places while waiting for it to dry. It is almost impossible to apply without getting it all over your lashes and it clumps there and looks like you've never used liner before. I've been using eyeliner since the 70's and am good enough that people have asked if my makeup is tattooed on, so it isn't a technique issue. I trimmed the brush fibers down to a very thin point, hoping this would help. Nope. It takes me almost ten minutes to get this to look like my previous liner and then it's so dark and dense that I look "goth." I don't recommend this at all. On the positive side, IF you manage to get it applied satisfactorily, it will last for at least 48 hours before showing any wear.