Liquid Eyeliner. VELVET ALL DAY WATERPROOF Liquid Eye Liner PENS. Smudge Proof. Multiple Colors to Choose from. (3 pack)- (charcoal)

Really enjoy the ease of application and thin line that I like. I haven't found anything I like better.Cons" Sometimes (not often) the product bleeds from the applicator -- especially during airline travel, but occasionally at home. And I wish it would last longer. I think the brush gets dried out and needs to be moistened to extend it's life. Would like to see directions addressing this.

I've bought these before as individual eyeliners in a retail package and they were great. I love this product and how easy it is to apply, but not this batch. This is the second time, I've purchased these from this manufacturer and find that despite what the manufacturer says, the product is not the same quality as the individual retail packaging and that it is bulk packaging, but it doesn't perform the same way as the individual retail ones. The black comes out very light (no matter how many times you shake it and try and start it).To get a decent thin black line with these you have to go over your lid multiple times. The result is a messy line instead of one nice clean line. Despite what the vendor says, I think these are manufacture defects because I've found that only 1 out of 6 worked properly. Not worth the money.

I like the way it works, very smooth and it has a great application brush . I like the black one but the one called “sea green” is hideous. It looks like a bright turquoise blue-green shade that your grandma would wear. I’m going to return that one. But they sent 3.

Well it's great but I was told it's being discontinued. I used to buy it at trade shows. But then the guy told me he was sorry but his family member that was making it was retiring and was closing the plant. Now not sure how true that is. So if you can still get it....IT IS AMAZING! It has a ball inside of it like nail polish. So you shake everytime you use it. Does not really dry out, because if it starts to just dip the end it water and shake. It becomes perfect again. Perfect liner, dried without smudging yet comes off with water. Amazing for a dramatic look!

I have used this before so knew what I was getting. It goes on very easily, stays all day with no smudges and washes off at night. The applicator is a thin brush. You can apply a thin line (which I like), or thicker, if you prefer. You do not have to be an expert to use Velvet Eyeliner I am using my original purchase since March-so it lasts. I highly recommend it. I only wish I could pick and choose colors but I usually do use black and the cost for a 3 pack was very good for me!

Love this eyeliner. Bought it for the first time at a state fair. However, the ones ordered through here seem very dry. Not as easy to apply as the ones previously purchased. You have to get the tip slightly damp to get the liquid flowing.

I bought this eyeliner at our state fair several years ago in a 3 pack of black, gray, and brown. The brown was all I had left and it was almost out, I don't know why I didn't look online sooner to find this brand, but tried a few other brands that I could buy at the store & they were NOT as good as this one. I have sensitive eyes and these do not irritate my eyes. It is easy to use and lasts a long time. I will always be buying this brand online from now on!

I was so happy to find this eyeliner on Amazon. I had bought this product at the Ohio State Fair, usually 2 at a time, which lasted me until I went to the fair the following year. This year though they weren't selling it so was glad I was able to get 3 of these, for just a little more than what I paid for 2. This liner goes on super smooth and I like it a lot better than a pencil eyeliner. I would recommend this product!