Physicians Formula Organic Wear All Natural Fake Out Mascara Black, Dermatologist Tested

I received the mascara, tried it but it was very dry

The production was totally dry. I had to throw it away...

Product was totally dry with an year old production date.

I was not at all sure about this when I first pulled it out of the box - the flat top, where you hold onto the wand felt weird and awkward the first couple times I used it. It only took a few tries to get used to, however, and the mascara is totally worth the effort! I have been very frustrated by "clean" mascaras (organic/all natural) because so few of them are actually dark! They tend to have a "natural" effect... i.e. they do very little of the volumizing or emphasizing of one's lashes that is so appealing in standard mascara! This one actually is an appreciably dark black, and adds both volume and emphasis. It takes more than one coat to the get look I want, but after two or three layers it looks just as good as the (sadly toxic) stuff I used to use. It does not irritate my eyes at all, and comes off completely cleanly and easily with a little bit of coconut oil. When smudged, it is also easily cleaned up and retouched. It DOES smudge - do not even think about rubbing your eyes or crying with this stuff on. I did not take off any stars for that, however, as it is apparently (and unfortunately) unavoidable in clean mascaras. Extensive reading of reviews for every mascara that gets safe ratings in the Skin Deep database sadly supports my own experience - easy smudge is just part of the price paid for not putting nasty chemicals near your eyes. *sigh* That said, as noted above, at least this mascara actually creates the look I have so missed being able to create and never irritates my eyes. Also, you can't beat the price! I was paying more than twice this much for another clean brand that smudged just as much and wasn't as dark. This is a good deal and a good product - definitely the best I've encountered so far, and I plan to stick with it!

Se ve que el producto no es reciente, no encontré por ningún lado la fecha de caducidad. Está completamente seco

My favorite mascara. Never causes irritation, glides on smooth. Been using it for well over a decade- suddenly Shoppers doesn't carry it. :( Their rebranded ones are terrible. I'm glad I can find it here ...

I like this one the best because it's organic and I don't have to worry about chemicals and additives my most favorite eye makeup. Unfortunately I'm having a hard time ordering it again because it's always out of stock

I think this mascara is kinda overrated. I wish it was waterproof, but it's not, it smeared all over the place. It's ok if you are not going to sweat or do anything on humid weather (I'll cal this a ~winter mascara~ xD) but otherwise, I wouldn't bother. I do admit it does give a nice fullness to the lashes, very natural and not clumpy.