365 by Whole Foods Market, Birthday Cake Sandwich Creme, 20 Ounce

Better than actual Oreo’s, overall better flavor and texture compared to birthday cake Golden Oreo’s, the price is comparable and I find these to be a better value, the price fluctuates somewhat, but even when the price goes up, they are still a better value over the name brand, the cookie sandwich pieces taste amazing, the cream fillings tastes very good and doesn’t have any artificial flavor whatsoever. I have purchased these cookies a couple times now and each time the entire package was gone in two days, I’d definitely recommend buying more than one at a time, I wish they sold them in bundle packs for a better deal. I’ve only tried the birthday cake flavor and none of the others, I’d imagine the other flavors are just as good if not better. These sandwich cookies go very very well with Nutella spread on them and eaten with ice cream, I did a bowl of birthday cake ice cream with these cookies and the pair was a match made in heaven…

I am absolutely OBSESSED with these birthday cake creme sandwich cookies! I just bought some sandwhich creme cookies for the same price and the box of birthday cake cookies is huge compared to the other ones I got for the same price. You definitely get your money's worth with these. I really love the creme in the middle. It tastes like the Dunk-a-Roos icing. I put a few of these in a cup and pour almond mylk over them and eat them immediately. They were soooo good! These are vegan friendly as well which is why I bought them. I have zero complaints with these cookies. 10/10! I couldn't stop eating these. Definitely order two boxes because they go fast!

I liked the crunchy sandwich cookie, but they are alittle sweet and rich. Something for a special occasion, they were a nice touch for my daughters bday.

Bought these hoping they would be a cheaper alternative to Annie’s birthday cake sandwich grahams which I love. This Whole Foods version (I got the birthday cake flavor) are just okay. They’re good enough to satisfy my sweet tooth but something about the sprinkles or creme filling has a slight strawberry flavor to it. I can’t pinpoint it, but when expecting a birthday cake flavor, it was a little off-putting. Probably wouldn’t buy again.

No seriously, if you have a problem w/ binge-eating, avoid these. It takes me back to days of past when I'd eat like 30 dunkaroos packages back-to-back. Similar flavor profile, indeed. The price could be lower given that the ingredients aren't that far off from similar products you'd find at Walmart, Aldi, Big Lots, or elsewhere, but the flavor is so delicious, that an argument can actually be made that the price gap is warranted.

I do not understand how these cookies have such amazing reviews. It's been years since I tasted something so disgusting! My 2 kids - who will eat anything sweet - spit them out and thew them away. I can't describe the taste. Just so bad. I rarely write reviews, especially negative ones, but someone's gotta warn people. If these were ever good, maybe I got a bad batch, but I strongly recommend saving your money. They are NOTHING like the birthday cake golden Oreos as I had hoped.

Wonderful flavor!!!!

These are fave our cookies! Super fresh and taste just like confetti birthday cake!