Sprout Waterproof Eyeliner | Smooth & Soft | Vegan Formula | Plantable Eyeliner Pencil with Wildflower Seeds | Makeup Gift | Black

I did not expect to love this eyeliner so much. I was just trying out a different brand than the one I've used for years. The old eyeliner was also from a company (pretty big name) that made more natural products, but the color faded by the end of the day, and if the weather was too hot, I had to watch for smeared eyeliner under my eyes.So I was shocked when this one stayed dark and in place all day. Wow! Love it.I ordered black. It's not as black as a liquid or gel, although if you wanted to put it on that dark, you could probably come close by building it up--but I don't want it that dark. I like that I can keep it lighter by not putting on as much. I also don't use it for the dramatic eyeliner looks, so I can't comment on that. I just want something that will define my top lid well and back up my mascara so my light eyelashes aren't invisible. This eyeliner delivers a lasting, natural look for me.It sharpens about as well as any other pencil eyeliner--not perfect but not bad. The packaging is great--doesn't leave you wondering if the product you received had been opened at some point. And it has the cute little seed part waiting to be planted. (My pencil said "wildflowers" on it, so I'm guessing they will all be labeled so you know what kind of seeds you have).Great idea. Great product.

It is soft so you don’t use much to apply - lasts longer! I have to be careful because if I press too hard, it will be really dark and I don’t want to look like I’m back in the 80s! 😂 I have sharpened it maybe 2 times with out breakage. It seems to stay on well and washes off without a lot of fuss.Good product, will purchase again.

I've been using this eyeliner for a year now, and what I can say is that I love it. My eyes are so sensitive, I've had some surgeries in my left eye, and after all of that I wanted something that was not gonna affect my eyes, I am so happy I was able to find that.

I used this right after the USPS guy handed it to me. It slides onto your lids without any friction, and the pigment stays on all day long. And I can't believe that when I'm done using this, I can stick this into the mud and expect a plant to sprout from it. It's an excellent purchase, one that I will most happily make over and over again. It's a premium product and a gift to the environment.

Really appreciated this purchase. It’s hard to find a totally natural cosmetic pencil that isn’t too soft. This one is just right for me. You can even plant the box it came in.

I bought this liner because it said it was waterproof, but my eyes seem too water constantly and the waterproof pencil seems to run from my eyes watering so I don’t know if it’s just my eyes or it’s not great as a waterproof pencil

Lovely stuff if you want to look like a 🤡 after one hour in the humidity. Kinda like you've been wearing the same makeup for several days. The company says "waterproof but not water proof, as you probably know". This is the worst eyeliner I have actually ever worn. Just buy a bag of seeds because that's all this stuff is worth.

Everyday I used this eyeliner I woke up with gunk in my eyes. Stopped use and it got better. Not their fault obviously. Otherwise it was cute and a great little idea. I didn’t know I had any allergies or I may not have tried it. Live and learn.