Maybelline New York Hyper Easy No Slip Pencil Eyeliner Makeup, Black, 0.001 oz.

Good price point. Glides on beautifully and effortlessly. Nice color. Only drawback, as with all of these, if you advance it too much, pencil breaks.

I honestly regret buying this eyeliner. It just doesn’t work. There’s barely any color payoff—nothing shows up when I try to apply it. If you apply too much pressure, it breaks easily. It’s honestly one of the worst eyeliners I’ve tried. Save your money and look for something that actually works.

Just what I had been searching for. The point stays sharp, making it easy to apply and the color stays on. I wish they made a lighter shade. I have very dark hair but I need to be careful of how much I apply. I will definitely order more.

I love maybelline products but this one misses the mark. I usually buy the skinny pencil, but was having a time finding the right color, so I tried this one. The penil is super thin and is very fragile. I've lost quit a bit just trying to get it to the right starting level. I don't use a heavy line but I need it to be a little sturdier to at least get a decent line. Next time I'll jut wait on the skinny liner.

I really love this eyeliner! It goes on smoothly it stays on all day it doesn’t bleed which I love. My only issue is it will break on you so you must be very careful and the tube is quite small so for this price I just buy two at a time.

"Great eyeliner

I really was hoping to like this as it would offer the flexibility due to it's thin tip. However it takes way too much pressure to get it to work. The tip was so dry that even the littlelest of pressure broke the tip off.

I thought the bad reviews might be people being too critical, but they're right. I'm not a picky person so I really try to give products a chance. No matter how little product I twist up, it snaps and breaks off. It feels hard and scratchy when I'm applying it. It doesn't glide on easily, creamy, or pigmented, I have to press firmly to get it to show and then it's just a faded black unless I go over it again. It's not long wearing like other eyeliners. The revlon version of this is much better. If you're trying to decide which one to get, I'd go with the Revlon. I'm always on the hunt for an alternative to the old discontinued L'Oreal microliner, it was a super skinny micro wooden pencil with it's own sharpener. Still can't find anything like it.