The Open Question: Ben Hogan and Golf's Most Enduring Controversy

Very well written. As a loyal fan of Mr. Hogan, I welcome any well written book about him, and there are several. This factual account of the 1942 Hale America National Open provides a window into the bureaucracy which can even invade this timeless sport. It is a worthwhile read for anyone interested in the history of golf and Mr. Hogan in particular.

Perhaps I am overly influenced by the recent Hemingway documentary but Peter May’s writing reminds me of Hemingway’s writing style. May’s ability to construct simple sentences and convey complex facts, emotions and historic consequences is indeed exceptional.May’s style shines in “The Open Question”and deftly provides the reader insights into US history, USGA history and the people who created these historic events.

This is a great read for any golf fan. I learned a ton about Hogan, his peers, and the era(s) in which they played. May makes a convincing case that Hogan should have 5 US Opens, not 4, and 10 major championships, not 9.

A well written, excellent book.

This is an excellent subject to write about, but the read is very disjointed. One paragraph you’re reading golf history and then it jumps to some random unrelated subject. I’m sure it is thoroughly researched but I did find some inaccuracies. As an avid golfer and a reader of hundreds of golf books, I can’t recommend this one.