Wet n Wild H2O Proof Felt Tip Liquid 884 Espresso

Great shade- striking, but not as harsh as black. After testing about a dozen kinds of liquid liners, I discovered this one. I won't buy anything else now. None of the expensive brands stay on this well. This liner will never smudge or run once it's dry. I hope they never stop making it. Hard to remove with just soap and water. Use a cotton ball or q-tip saturated with olive oil. Works like a charm.

I do love this product, I only wish they would make ONE a bit lighter in color. I have bought severl over the years, black, dark brown and thisEspresso. Like I said , I wish there was one made only a bit lighter brown..

Don't know if the product I received was old or what, because it comes out really transparent when I apply it (even after I shake it), so I have to reapply a couple of times. I have this product in black as well, and it doesn't do that, so idk what the deal is.

the best waterproof liquid eyeliner I have found. It literally wont come off unless you use soap and water. Water alone wont do it. I used to buy this color at the drugstore but I think it has been discontinued so I found it here on Amazon. I will definitely be buying this again.

While the eyeliner does what it's supposed to do and stays on under the hot Hawaiian sun, it can't handle being in actual water without flaking and gobbing up in my eyelashes. (I did try to swim in it... since the packaging says 'waterproof'!) I'll be honest, I've only tried the product twice, because the second time I wore it, it burnt my eyelids and I had to take it all off after a few minutes. (It did the first time too, but not as badly.) It wasn't too bad, but painful enough for me to never use this product again.It looks nice when it first goes on, but isn't really waterproof, and I think the waterproof formula gave me an allergic reaction or something. (I've never had any problem with a makeup product before - especially not burning...) So, my advice is, try this stuff out on your skin before you try it on your eyes. It does apply pretty easily and has staying power - it's a nice color as well; too bad it didn't work for me :(Anyway, I gave it 2 stars because it does exactly what my 3$ gel liner can do, and the gel doesn't set my eyelids on fire.

Product was a little old and stringy. This is a great product unless it gets old, then too stringy to apply easily.

I like a thin line, that show's up. Tired of using an expensive product that can't seem to line 1 entire eye lid without redipping. Sort of ruins the look to go back & finish. This product works.

Goes on very well, just a little darker than expected