Collapsible -45 Gallon Canvas Garden Waste Bag -Pop-up Bucket Reusable Yard Leaf Bag Holder- Heavy Duty Hardshell Bottom – with Drain Holes for Lawn Pool Garden Camping Trash Debris Bag with Handles

Perfect weed bag for gardening. Heavy duty, large capacity, handles make it easy to pull around. Can leave bag in the rain and with the water flows through bottom. Base is sturdy and stands up on its own. Liked it so much I bought another one.

I've been using different collapsible garden/weeding bags for 25+ years, and this one is the best by far. Here are the reasons: (1) Hard sturdy plastic base, with drainage; (2) Very strong wire spring, ensuring the bag stays upright as you load it; (3) Easy to use clips on the OUTSIDE of the bag, for collapsing & storage. All previous bags I've used quickly get holes in their plain fabric base after 1-2 seasons, as you drag them around the yard. BUT -- this bag's hard plastic base "scuffs" very smoothly over the surface of gravel or other hardscape. Also -- it has drainage! If you leave a half-pile of weeds in it overnight, or forget to dump it before it rains, no problem! You can also easily rinse the bag out & it will dry/drain. ALSO -- the wire spring seems to be much stronger than all other bags; this bag stands upright vs. collapsing to the side when you try to stuff in taller branch trimmings. AND -- when you want to collapse the whole thing, you don't have to grope inside the edge of the dirty bottom liner to grasp a tiny toggle to hook up to an outside loop -- this bag's plastic snap connections are BOTH cleanly on the outside & easy to connect, once you've dumped the bag into your yard-waste bin & done. I chose the 18" diameter because it fit into the narrow gravel pathways in my yard & I thought its lower weight would allow me to easily lift & dump it into my larger yard bin. But, I am sure the 22" diameter would be equally hefty & an awesome choice if you were a stronger individual with a larger yard. I love this bag!!! I'm not going to say it makes weeding fun, but it makes weeding kind of fun. If you've had bad experiences with other pop-up bags, get this one with no worries!!

Lasts us about 3 years before garbage

This replaced one that I used for years that finally was worn out. I've used this extensively the past two seasons it is good quality and durable. I would recommend.

This has been a great purchase for me it’s very light weight and I love that it can be collapsed to store away. I could have done without the upper cover it gets in the way.

I've been using my bag regularly for my gardening business work since I received it about a month ago, and so far, it's been great. I soon found the best answer to my question, above, about the drawstring top potentially interfering with unloading the contents: you don't need to fold this top over the outside of the bag to keep it from interfering with emptying the contents, after all. That's great, because doing prevents one's access to the top handles, which in my case would be a real sacrifice in functionality. Instead, you can just leave the drawstring top inside the bag; when you dump the contents out, the top is loose enough that it just falls out of the bag easily without even remotely trying to catch any of the contents on their way out.Incidentally, after I received my bag, I had emailed the small, family-owned company (which warmly invited feedback in their flyer accompanying my purchase) about these concerns, but they never got back to me. Luckily, I did not impulsively cut the drawstring top off in impatience for an answer, but instead, I just tried various ways of handling the top till I got supremely lazy and just left it on the inside, at which point my question was answered!Also interestingly, I just found out that Garden Supply Company makes an almost identical product. The main differences are that theirs is made of polyester and polypropylene and that the bottom handle drags on the ground--an arrangement that I've found is a liability because it tends to make this handle to wear out much more quickly than it would otherwise.

just what my wife needed for working her flower gardens

When using this leaf bag a few weeks ago, I grabbed the handle and it came off so easily! I was shocked. I then used the other handle and that handle came off on one side. On Amazon, the product page says "That's why we protect you with a full 24-month warranty". So with that stated on Amazon's page for this product, I would either like my money back or a new bag sent to me.