Maybelline Unstoppable Waterproof Mechanical Black Eyeliner Pencil, Easy to Apply, Smooth Glide, Up to 24 Hour Wear, Onyx

Reasonably priced and the brown is a perfect brown.. Very slender point & smudgeable ti soften the line. Not waterproof but a very daily liner.

Being an older woman I want to apply makeup that looks natural and understated, and this grey eyeliner fits the bill. No more black eyeliner for me at this age. I find this easy to use, lasts all day, comes off easily at night with my makeup removed sheet.

This eyeliner goes on smoothly, stays put for a lengthy period of time and looks great.

Very Smooth but NOT waterproof. I have very oily skin so Im always trying to find a liner tht WONT smear. I like KAT VON Ds liners but they dry to fast b4 i even get to play with it. I wore this and its doooo easy ti apply. Very milky.l but i noticed after 8 hrs of wear product was missing & smeared. Not crazy bad but noticeable :( Ill keep searching.

This is the only eyeliner I wear! It lasts all day, no need to sharpen as it just twists up! Doesn’t irritate my eyes and takes no time to dry! Very bold black color!

I love this, the coverage works well. It is worth the value. It lasts all day. I rebuy this after I run out of- everytime! This is my favorite product

Doesn't smudge. Color as described. Bold enough

Keeps breaking. Not really that black - takes a lot of work to make it dark enough. Not my favorite but works for now I guess.

Es larga duración pero si lo aplicas sobre la línea de agua no dura tanto y tiende a recorrerse por el párpado inferior, hay que retocar lo a las 3 o 4 horas.

Made my eyelids swell up and hurt my eyes.

Fantastic stays in place, just where you put it not everywhere you dont want it! Goes on smoothly and great for the waterline, I have tried 100s and this is up with those costing 3 or 4 times the price!

Been using this for years and its perfect, no bleeding and goes on easily

Soo average.... try it if it comes at a bargain