Tarte Tarteist Clay Paint Waterproof Eye Liner- Black Full Size w/Angled Brush

I have extremely sensitive eyes and I was at a loss with gel liners and coal liners irritating my eyes. I finally after doing some research and last ditch effort thought, I use Tarte Amazonian Clay for my foundation and blush why not try it for the eye liner. WOW, am I amazed. This is a great matte black that goes on easily and stays on. Does not budge but comes off easily and does not irritate my eyes. Such a plus. Why I never got this before is beyond me. Plus, I actually love the container it comes in. You can put out the exact amount you need and no additional bacteria gets into your product. Plus it keeps it from drying out.

I like the brush and the eyeliner. Does smudge a bit.

This is my second one and it's the only liquid eyeliner that I can't live without. I complement it with a precision liner for sharp wings. The best thing about this is that it stays put. No matter the heat or sweat, the liner will not transfer to my lids. The little brush is handy and is great for thicker wings.

This eyeliner is super easy to use and has super longevity i love it . I couldn't find it in stores i always go to so i just order it hear instead.

PROS: The product goes on well, and stays put for hours! The brush is super easy to use - right out of the gate, even...very little practice time required getting used to the brush.CONS: It does smudge. Not a ton right away, but enough to notice - and by the end of the day I'm kind of a smudgy mess. The thing I'd like Tarte to change most though, is the color. When I line my eyes, I'd much rather use a lighter, softer color than KOHL BLACK... a brown would be ideal. The plastic tube it comes in really should be replaced with something else too... it clogs easily, and it isn't easy to regulate how much (or how little) comes out. Pricey too!

Easy to remove with soap and water

Love this eyeliner, sad they’re not making it anymore

I read some good reviews on this so I tried it and i loved it, in the beginning. The lines were really dark, defined and precise. Then at the end of the day, when I got home and looked in the mirror, i had sort of racoon eyes. Yep, it smeared. I guess it does say clay based but I didn't expect it to smear/smudge even after setting it with setting spray. Well you can't win them all. Great concept though!

I heard plenty of positive reviews about this product and I can't fault it.The best liner by far I've ever purchased. Glides on smoothly, matt black and does not smudge throughout the day.

Good product, lasts longer on eyelid than other products I've had

The product was small for the price. I didn't realise it was going to be that size. I wouldn't have purchase it. But all the same it's quite good

The application of this product is fantastic, applies like a liquid and the precise brush makes life so much easier so my first impression was amazing. However! This eyeliner has no staying power at all!! I found smudged patches under my eyes after wearing all day which I've never experienced before, and if you wipe it it will smudge right off/spread, so if you touch your face etc which does happen your make up will be... InterestingIf the eyeiner was way cheaper I probably wouldn't be very upset, but I invested in a more expensive brand so try and get a cleaner line so it's not great!